In April, two brick-front Colonials on Yuma Street NW came on the market together. Both had been reworked by the developer District495, and both sat in Spring Valley West. 5117 Yuma was priced at $3.295 million and 5119 Yuma at $4.295 million, according to a sponsored UrbanTurf feature from April 16.
DC's public property records show how each one ended. 5117 Yuma sold for $3,295,000 on May 14, 2026, at its April asking price and less than a month after launch. 5119 Yuma, a house W.C. and A.N. Miller built in 1987, sold on September 15 for $3,900,000. That was $395,000 under its spring ask, and it closed five months later.
The same builder, finish level and street produced two different timelines. If you own an older Spring Valley house and are deciding between listing in the next few weeks and waiting for March, these two sales matter more than any citywide median. In spring, an original house in this neighborhood is shown and priced next to finished rebuilds like these. Choosing a season mostly means choosing which comparison your house will face.
What these houses sold for before the work, and after
Spring Valley seldom sees ground-up construction. District495's marketing for the Yuma houses noted that Spring Valley West had seen no significant new building since the Millers built there in the 1980s and 1990s. Since 2025, several existing houses and lots have changed hands and come back as new or rebuilt homes. The DC Office of Tax and Revenue's public extract, updated November 13, 2026, records the sales before and after the work.
| Address | What it was | Sale date | Recorded price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5118 Albemarle St NW | Lot recorded as vacant | May 6, 2025 | $1,020,000 |
| 4827 Sedgwick St NW | 1948 Colonial, later rebuilt | May 8, 2025 | $1,800,000 |
| 5117 Yuma St NW | District495 reworked Colonial | May 14, 2026 | $3,295,000 |
| 4939 Quebec St NW | Akseizer Residential new construction | August 21, 2026 | $6,100,000 |
| 3949 52nd St NW | 2017 Colonial, resale | September 3, 2026 | $9,500,000 |
| 5119 Yuma St NW | District495 reworked Colonial | September 15, 2026 | $3,900,000 |
The table shows two price levels. A vacant lot on Albemarle sold for about $1 million, and the 1948 house on Sedgwick Street sold for $1.8 million before it was taken down to its shell and rebuilt at roughly 5,000 square feet across four levels. Finished product sold for between $3.3 million and $6.1 million. That is the kind of house an unrenovated Colonial on the next block will be measured against.
The top line belongs to a house that was already finished. 3949 52nd Street, a 2017 house, set a Spring Valley record at $9.5 million. The Washington Business Journal reported that it last sold in 2019 for $7.75 million. Its builder was Richard Zantzinger and its architect was Barnes Vanze Architects. Both names carry weight with buyers at this level, and neither tells you much about what an original Miller Colonial will bring.
For an owner, the useful range lies between the $1.8 million Sedgwick sale and the $3.3 million Yuma sale. Somewhere in that range is your house as it stands today. Where it lands depends on whether a buyer sees a house to move into or a project, and that judgment gets sharper when a finished version of the same kind of house is on the market nearby.
The finished houses a spring buyer has already seen
District495's second project, The Grove at Spring Valley, comes from the same assembly of land as the Yuma houses. The original owner of 5119 Yuma had gradually bought the house next door plus two properties on Albemarle Street, and District495 later bought all of it and split it into two projects. A second sponsored UrbanTurf feature, dated October 7, listed the Grove's three homes at five bedrooms, six and a half baths and nearly 6,000 square feet each. It said one was already under contract and that 5118 and 5122 Albemarle were priced in the mid $4 millions. The houses sit just above Yuma Street on a cul-de-sac next to protected land.
For an owner thinking about March, this is the standard that counts. The Grove homes are already on the market, so whether any of them is still for sale in spring or not, a buyer shopping Spring Valley in the $3 million to $4.5 million range will have seen what a finished house there looks like. The Grove marketing names Thermador appliances, Waterworks fixtures, EV charger outlets and an elevator shaft framed and wired for later. An original house can still win on lot, street or architecture, a point we made in our September look at Spring Valley's fastest sale. It will still be compared.
The more inventory of this kind is on the market, the more a well-kept 1940s house gets priced as a project. Spring is when there is the most of it. In a February conversation with WTOP, one local agent called mid-March through mid-May the most active eight-week stretch of the year. He said family-size homes in desirable close-in neighborhoods draw the most competition, because families aim to settle around the end of the school year. The same buyers bring more sellers with them.
What the winter calendar changes, citywide
The seasonal figures below cover all of Washington, D.C., not Spring Valley alone. They come from Bright MLS data published by the DC Association of Realtors and the Greater Capital Area Association of Realtors.
In December 2025, 330 new listings came on the market across the District. Average days on market was 49, and homes sold for an average of 95.0% of their original list price. January 2026 brought 638 new listings, an average of 62 days on market and a 94.4% ratio. In April 2026, new listings rose to 1,112, with 50 days on market and a 96.5% ratio. May 2026 had the best terms for sellers, with 41 days and 97.7% of original list.
Put simply, a December seller last year competed with about a third of the new listings an April seller did, and accepted about a point and a half less of original list price on average. For a $2.5 million house, a point and a half is roughly $37,500. That is real money. For an original Spring Valley house, it may still cost less than being shown in April next to a rebuilt Colonial on the next street.
This winter starts from a softer position than last winter did. In October 2026, the District had 975 new listings, 11.6% fewer than in October 2025. Active listings reached 3,070, and months of supply stood at 6.2, against a five-year October average of 4.0. The median home sold in 18 days, at 94.8% of original list price. In its October 2026 report, released November 9, Bright MLS said it expects sluggish sales through year-end and rising inventory.
In Washingtonian's October 29 survey of 100 area agents, 76% called this fall more of a buyer's market and 85% said inventory is rising. The agents described Thanksgiving as the start of the slowest stretch of the year, with a possible small bump in December from buyers trying to close before year-end. They named pricing as the top factor in selling right now.
Matching the season to the house
Taken together, the Spring Valley records and the citywide calendar point to a fairly practical decision.
An owner whose house is finished, updated and ready to show has less reason to hurry. Spring brings the most buyers, and a finished house holds up next to the Grove homes and the Sedgwick rebuild. The 5117 Yuma sale at full price in May is the local example.
An owner whose house is original or partly updated faces different math. The buyers likeliest to pay well for that house are the ones who want the street and the lot and plan to renovate on their own schedule. A winter listing reaches them with far fewer new listings around it. It also avoids a March showing in which the house down the street has heated marble floors and yours has 1950s tile.
Winter also has practical costs. In the same WTOP interview, the agent noted that some systems, air conditioning among them, can't be fully tested when temperatures fall below the mid-50s. He also said roofs and gutters often take a beating from snow and ice and are worth inspecting before a listing.
Some owners take a middle course. Agents in the Washingtonian survey said some sellers wait for spring but test the market over the holidays with private exclusives, so the listing doesn't build up days on market. For an original house, a quiet December test can show whether a renovating buyer is out there at your number before you commit to a spring launch against new construction.
Two questions owners ask about these numbers
Does the $9.5 million record raise what an older house is worth? Not directly. 3949 52nd Street was a 2017 house with a named builder and architect, and it was resold as finished product. It shows how far the top of the market reaches. The 2025 sale on Sedgwick Street and the Yuma sales are closer comparisons for an original Colonial.
What separated the two Yuma sales? Price. 5117 sold at $3.295 million in May. 5119 was priced a million dollars higher and closed in September for $3.9 million. In Spring Valley this year, the lower-priced finished house sold first and at its full asking price.
If you own an older house in Spring Valley and are weighing a quiet December listing against a March launch, Jack Realty Group can go through it with you. That includes where your house falls between the 2025 pre-rebuild sales and the 2026 finished sales, and which finished homes buyers will be comparing yours with when you list. Start with a home valuation, or book a neighborhood consultation and we will set the calendar around your house.